Skip to content 
Why Are Some Knives Hard to Sharpen? If you’ve ever spent time trying to bring a dull knife back to life, you may have noticed that not all knives respond the same way. Some blades quickly regain their edge with a few passes over a sharpening stone, while others seem to resist no matter how much effort you put in. At Knife Tech, Sydney’s trusted blade experts, we’ve sharpened thousands of knives for chefs, restaurants, and home cooks, and one question we often hear is: “Why is my knife so hard to sharpen?”
The answer lies in a mix of factors — from the type of steel to the design of the blade. In this article, we’ll break down the reasons why some knives are more difficult to sharpen and what you can do about it.
1. The Type of Steel Matters
The steel your knife is made from plays a huge role in how easy or difficult it is to sharpen.
- Harder steels (like high-carbon stainless or tool steel): These steels hold an edge for a long time, which is great for durability, but they also take more effort to sharpen. You’ll need the right abrasives and technique.
- Softer steels (like lower carbon stainless): These are easier to sharpen but tend to lose their edge more quickly.
In short, if your knife is made from premium steel, expect it to take longer to sharpen — but the payoff is a sharper edge that lasts much longer.
2. Blade Thickness and Geometry
Another factor is the geometry of the blade. Knives with thicker spines or steeper cutting angles naturally resist sharpening. For example:
- Chef’s knives with a wide bevel: They often need more work to get the entire bevel sharp.
- Thin Japanese knives (like Santokus or Gyutos): These sharpen more easily because they have a narrow angle.
- Serrated knives: These are notoriously difficult to sharpen because each tooth must be sharpened individually.
Blade design plays a major role in the sharpening process, so the knife’s shape can determine whether it’s a quick tune-up or a time-consuming job.
3. Heat Treatment of the Steel
Even knives made from the same type of steel can behave differently depending on how they were heat-treated during manufacturing.
- Properly heat-treated knives: Have balanced hardness and toughness, making them easier to sharpen and maintain.
- Improperly treated knives: Can be brittle, soft, or inconsistent in hardness, making sharpening unpredictable.
High-end knives from reputable brands usually have excellent heat treatment, but cheaper mass-produced knives often don’t.
4. Knife Damage or Wear
Sometimes, it’s not the steel or the blade design — it’s the condition of the knife itself.
- Chips or nicks in the edge: These require extra time and effort to grind away before the blade can be sharpened.
- Rolled or bent edges: Caused by frequent use on hard surfaces like glass or stone, which makes sharpening more difficult.
- Excessive wear: Over years of use, knives can become uneven, requiring re-profiling before they can be properly sharpened again.
If your knife is in poor condition, sharpening can take much longer and require professional attention.
5. Incorrect Sharpening Technique
Even the best knives can seem impossible to sharpen if the wrong technique is used. Common mistakes include:
- Using the wrong sharpening angle: Each knife has an ideal sharpening angle (usually between 15°–20°). Too steep or too shallow won’t work.
- Using the wrong tools: Cheap pull-through sharpeners or dull sharpening stones can do more harm than good.
- Inconsistent strokes: Uneven pressure or irregular passes over the sharpening stone results in an uneven edge.
A poor technique doesn’t just make sharpening harder — it can also damage your blade.
6. Low-Quality Knives
Unfortunately, some knives are just poorly made. Low-cost knives made with inferior materials can be extremely frustrating to sharpen. These knives often:
- Have inconsistent steel hardness along the blade
- Lose their edge almost immediately after sharpening
- Don’t respond well to traditional sharpening tools
In these cases, it’s often worth investing in a higher-quality knife rather than struggling with poor steel.
7. Specialized Knife Types
Certain specialty knives are more difficult to sharpen simply due to their design. Examples include:
- Serrated knives – require a special sharpener or professional service.
- Ceramic knives – very hard and brittle, needing diamond sharpeners.
- Double-bevel vs. single-bevel Japanese knives – single-bevel knives require advanced technique.
If you own one of these specialty knives, it’s usually best to leave sharpening to professionals like us at Knife Tech.
Tips to Make Sharpening Easier
Now that you know why some knives are hard to sharpen, here are a few tips to make the process smoother:
- Know your steel – Research the type of steel your knife is made of so you can use the right sharpening tools.
- Use quality sharpening equipment – Invest in good whetstones, diamond stones, or honing rods.
- Maintain your knives regularly – Don’t wait until they’re completely dull. Touch them up often.
- Avoid hard surfaces – Cutting on glass, ceramic, or stone will ruin your edge quickly.
- Seek professional sharpening – For high-end, damaged, or specialty knives, a professional service ensures the best results.
Why Professional Knife Sharpening is Worth It
While home sharpening is possible, some knives are just too valuable or too difficult to risk damaging. At Knife Tech, we specialize in restoring edges to professional-grade sharpness, no matter how challenging the knife. Our team uses advanced equipment and years of expertise to handle everything from premium Japanese knives to everyday kitchen blades.
By choosing professional sharpening, you’ll:
- Extend the lifespan of your knives
- Ensure a razor-sharp, safe edge
- Save time and frustration
- Protect your investment in quality cutlery
Conclusion
So, why are some knives hard to sharpen? The answer comes down to steel type, blade design, heat treatment, wear and damage, and sharpening technique. Some knives naturally require more effort, while others may simply need the right tools or a professional touch.
If your knife has been giving you trouble, don’t waste time and energy fighting it — let Sydney’s trusted experts at Knife Tech bring your blades back to life.
FAQs: Why Are Some Knives Hard to Sharpen?
Q1: Why are some knives hard to sharpen even with good tools?
Some knives are made from harder steels or designed with thicker blades, which naturally take longer to sharpen. Others may have poor heat treatment or damage that makes sharpening more difficult. This is one of the main reasons people ask, why are some knives hard to sharpen?
Q2: Can cheap knives be harder to sharpen than expensive ones?
Yes. Low-quality knives are often made from inconsistent steel that doesn’t respond well to sharpening tools. While they may be easier to grind, they don’t hold an edge, which makes people wonder why are some knives hard to sharpen compared to higher-quality ones.
Q3: Do professional services make sharpening easier?
Absolutely. Professionals use advanced tools to handle tough steels, damaged edges, or specialty knives. If you’re frustrated and asking yourself, why are some knives hard to sharpen at home?, it’s a good sign you may need expert help.
